What does a person expect on a first date?
Casey and Aaron have nothing in common: Aaron is a conservative, Jewish, relationship-seeking banker, while Casey is an artist, too funky for Wall Street.
With the influences of their friends and family (played out in their imaginations) as well as the effects of social media, this first date seems doomed to failure.
But with the help of an intrusive yet well-meaning server, Casey and Aaron could make a connection after all.
Find some excerpts from the musical when it was on Broadway in 2013: